Fly Fishing vs Spin Fishing: An Anglers Insight
Fly fishing and spin fishing are two of the most popular types of fishing, especially when it comes to North Georgia trout fishing. They both have their pros and cons, but which one is better? This is an age old argument and people from far and wide land on both sides. But is there a right answer? Let's take a closer look at the differences between fly fishing and spin fishing to see which one comes out on top!
The Differences in Fly Fishing vs Spin Fishing
Fly fishing is a type of fishing that uses a fly rod and artificial flies to catch fish. This type of fishing is often considered more challenging and rewarding than regular fishing. Fly fishing can be done in both freshwater and saltwater environments.
Fly fishing is different from spin fishing in a few ways, but it primarily comes down to the type of equipment you're using. Fly fishing requires the use of a fly rod with a weighted line and tapered leader that propels the fly forward when casting. Spin fishing depends on using a weightless line with a weighted lure in order to get your cast out there. Secondly, fly fishing utilizes artificial flies that are meant to best mimic what the trout are eating at the time. Spin fishing uses tackle or artificial lures that also mimic bait fish, but don't necessarily do as good of a job when it comes to looking as similar as possible to the trouts food.
Finally, fly fishing is typically done with a more flexible rod, while spin fishing rods can be a bit more rigid due to the fact they are casting heavier lures. This is all a part of the design and art of the type of fishing. With fly fishing, you need a more flexible rod because your ability to cast further and more accurately depends on the ability of the rod to load energy into the line to propel it forward. This is a major difference between the two types of fishing. Fly fishing requires a delicate aerial dance with your line and fly. This is also where most beginners are the most frustrated because we've all had our line get into those tangled messes when we are learning this art.
With spinner rods, they tend to be a bit more rigid because the weight of the lure is what will propel the lure forward when casting. Spinner fishermen are able to flick the wrist one time and launch their lure where they want it to go. Because of this, you can't really use a spinner rod to fish with a fly and you can't use a fly rod to fish with artificial lures.
The Benefits
The Benefits of Fly Fishing
While fly fishing is notoriously more difficult than spin fishing, the rewards are well worth it. Fly fishing requires much time and patience, especially as your starting out and learning the ins and outs of the sport. It also allows you to fish some truly remarkable destinations that spin fishing just simply won't allow. Another benefit is that trout eat insects. The best way to mimic an insect is with a fly.
One of the greatests benefits of fly fishing, in our humble opinion, is the intimacy with the water that it breeds. To be a successful fly fisherman, you really need to have an intimate knowledge of the water and the insect life that is found within that water. To learn and understand the different features in a body of water that are most likely to keep trout is truly an academic process.
It also differs on each body of water that you fish. For example, our Toccoa River fly fishing trips are vastly different than our Soque River fly fishing trips. To have an understanding of what features to look for in a river that are conducive for holding trout will radically help your chances of hooking into one. Pairing that with your knowledge of insect life and the various stages they go through is such a tedious, but rewarding process. There is nothing quite as spectacular as hooking into a 20+ inch brown trout on a dry fly and then delicately wrangling him into your net after reading and assessing the water that day.
As challenging as fly fishing can be, it certainly reaps a reward far greater than any frustrations you encounter along the way.
The Benefits of Spin Fishing
Spin fishing is an incredibly popular type of fishing because it's easy to learn, versatile, and can be enjoyed in both freshwater and saltwater environments. Although fly fisherman are certainly giving spin fisherman a run for their money in saltwater now as well! One of the primary benefits of spin fishing is that it has a low barrier to entry. Anyone can pick up a spinner rod and head out fishing. This makes it easier for beginners who are just starting out because you don't have to worry about casting a fly accurately and having all of the knowledge that fly fishing requires.
Spin fishing is also ideal for catching larger fish since you can use heavier lures that appeal to bigger fish. Additionally, you can use artificial lures that look like bait fish, making it easier for fish to mistake them for food. Lastly, with spin fishing you don't really need to have an intimate knowledge of the prey base. Most of the time you can catch a variety of fish with the same lure and it's not dependent upon each species.
Both fly fishing and spin fishing have their own unique benefits that make them enjoyable for anglers of all levels. So which one is better? The answer really depends on what you're looking for in a day out on the water. If you're looking for a more challenging and rewarding experience, then fly fishing is definitely the way to go! However, if you're just starting out and don't want to worry about mastering fly casting, spinning might be the better option.
Ultimately, though, it comes down to what type of experience you're looking for and what your preference is. Both fly fishing and spin fishing offer unique experiences that can appeal to both beginner and advanced anglers alike! A day on the water is well spent no matter what type of fishing you are doing!
The Drawbacks
The Drawbacks of Fly Fishing
Although fly fishing does have a number of benefits over spin fishing, it also has its drawbacks. One of the primary disadvantages is that fly fishing can be quite challenging, especially for beginners. It takes time and practice to learn how to cast a fly accurately and read the water correctly in order to locate fish. This can be frustrating for anglers who are just starting out and aren't used to the added difficulty of fly fishing.
Another drawback of fly fishing is that it can be expensive. You need to invest in a fly rod, fly reel, fly line, flies, and other accessories in order to get started. This can add up quickly, especially if you're looking to purchase quality gear. Additionally, fly fishing can be quite time consuming. It often takes longer to catch a fish on a fly than it does with a spinning rod. This isn't always the case, but it's something to consider if you're short on time.
Lastly, fly fishing requires an intimate knowledge of the insect life in the water you're fishing. While we consider this a benefit of fly fishing, it's not for everyone. If you're not familiar with what insects live in your area and what stage they are in, you may have trouble catching fish on a fly. Hatch Charts are a great way to supplement while you’re learning this art. You can check out a recent article we wrote on Trout Fishing in Helen GA that includes a hatch chart for North Georgia.
The Drawbacks of Spin Fishing
Just like fly fishing, spin fishing has its own set of drawbacks. One of the biggest disadvantages is that it's easy to become complacent when spin fishing. Since it's so easy to catch fish with this method, some anglers don't take the time to learn about their prey and simply rely on using artificial lures that look like bait fish. This can lead to a lack of success when targeting certain species of fish.
Additionally, spin fishing can be quite loud due to the heavier lures you're casting. This can spook fish and make them less likely to bite your lure. Another downside is that spin fishing gear is often equally as expensive as fly gear when you factor in rods, reels, lines, lures etc... However, the cost difference between good quality fly and spin gear is starting to narrow these days!
So Which One Is Best?
Both fly fishing and spin fishing have their own unique benefits and drawbacks that make them enjoyable for anglers of all levels! So which one is better? The answer really depends on what you're looking for in a day out on the water like we mentioned before. Just know that there is no wrong answer here!
A lot of anglers, myself included, use both methods of fishing. It's all dependent on what you're comfortable with, where your skill sets are and if you enjoy it! Fishing is all about enjoying time on the water, especially when you have fishing buddies to bring along with you. So no matter if you're spin fishing or fly fishing, just get out there and have fun!